Infidel:

The Harrowing Tale of My Wikipedia Edit

by Clifton Smith

When surfing the Web recently for info on writer/infidel Ayaan Hirsi Ali, I notice that her Wikipedia entry contains many “citation needed” notices.

Good Samaritan that I try to be, I decide to try to improve the quality and reliability of this Wikipedia entry.

Better Samaritan that I try to be, I decide to share with [sic] readers how this process unfolds.

Awesome.

Here are the first visible, default contents of Wikipedia’s Ayaan Hirsi Ali entry:

Many, perhaps most, Wikipedia articles look like this when they are first accessed.

The body of the article appears after the introduction and the table of contents:


I have circled the “citation needed” notices.

It is in the opening paragraph of the entry’s body that I find the first “citation needed” notice:

The “citation needed” notice makes me stop and re-read the sentence it applies to: “Shortly after she was born, her father was imprisoned due to his opposition to Somalia’s Siad Barre government.”

In Infidel, Hirsi Ali writes about her father, Hirsi Magan Isse, and his imprisonment. However, as far as I can tell, she never explains the cause of his imprisonment. We might assume from information she does give that he was imprisoned due to his opposition to Barre*. However, I prefer to base my understanding on as few assumptions as possible, as often as possible.

So, I seek out other sources to find the cause of Magan Isse’s imprisonment. After a few hours of searching around the Web, I find two sources I think confirm the statement the original author of the sentence made. One source is The Economist:

The family’s troubles began in 1969, the year Ms Hirsi Ali was born. That was also the year that Mohammed Siad Barre, a Somali army commander, seized power in a military coup. Hirsi Magan was descended from the traditional rulers of the Darod, Somalia’s second biggest clan. Siad Barre, who hailed from a lesser Darod family, feared and resented Ms Hirsi Ali’s father’s family, she says. In 1972, Siad Barre had Hirsi Magan put in prison from which he escaped three years later and fled the country.

Another source is Alexander Linklater’s report in The Guardian. It contains the following:

“I remember going to school and singing, and then my mother saying, ‘When you go to school today, don’t sing, because the songs that you sing are praise-songs for the man who locked up your father.’ ”

She remembers Siad Barre’s soldiers coming to the door one day and the tiny figure of her grandmother, knife in hand, standing up to the men and being tossed to the ground like a doll, in startling contravention of traditions of respect for older women as the men ransacked hidden supplies of food smuggled in by her mother.

I feel confident that both sources are good for my purposes. So, I will add both as citations to the Wikipedia article.

According to the Wikipedia entry on citing sources, contributors should try to be as consistent as possible within the article. Where possible, contributors should use the same citation format as the document’s originator.

I notice that both of the sources I’ve gathered are already being used in the article. I click the “edit this page” tab at the top of the article page.*

This allows me to view the source code of the page:

I search for and find the citation for The Guardian article:

I see that I can copy this code almost exactly for my own citation. I only need to change the “retrieved” date. So, I copy the reference entry.

I am ready to paste the code back into the document in the appropriate place.

The code that makes “[citation needed]” appear is as follows:

{{fact | date = March 2008}}*

I remove this code and replace it as follows:

I then click “Show Preview.” This allows me to look at my changes without actually applying them. I can see the citation looks as it should. The reference section at the bottom of the page also looks as it should. I apply my change.

I then add the citation for The Economist newspaper. I don’t have the publication information handy because I viewed the copy at a public library and neglected to write it down. So, I list the article title and the publication date range listed on the cover. I then add the quote that supports the statement I’m adding the citation for.

I later return to the library and record pertinent descriptive information (for example, the volume and page number) from a physical copy of The Economist. I then update my citation to show this extra information.

I scrutinize my work once more and deeply approve of myself and what I’ve done. I scoot back from my desk and go to the fridge where I withdraw a Leinenkugel. I unscrew the lid as I walk back to my desk. I sit back and bask in my glorious wonderfulness.

Top

This entry is filed under Current Events, Education, Politics, Reference. Find similar posts by selecting and of the following tags: . You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

RSS feed | Trackback URI

5 Comments »

Comment by Sci-Fi Bri
2008-06-25 08:01:37

Nice.

Could you check in on how LL Cool J is doing? I hear he still thinks that fatties have led to more research on bacon.

Comment by Clifton - Editor
2008-06-25 19:02:00

Nice try, Sci-Fi Bri!*

However, LL’s Wikipedia entry shows no such vandalism.

Wikipedia: 1
Bacon researchers: 0

 
 
Comment by Arius
2008-06-26 08:35:21

Also, please save the Lightsaber Combat page from deletion.

Comment by Clifton - Editor
2008-06-27 06:25:28

I only read a bit of the info in the lightsaber entry and a bit of the article where Wikipedia users present arguments for and against deletion.

Personally, I find the information presented to be pretty interesting. I might like to see it combed over a bit for style consistency. I might also like to see a better “References” section.

On the other hand, it seems possible to me that the Wookiepedia entry covering the same topic might already be a better alternative.

I suppose I will leave it to those with a greater devotion to the Star Wars franchise.

 
 
Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
Your Web Address (optional)
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
Your comment will post after moderator approval. For more information, see our comment guidelines.

You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

  1. Recent Posts

  2. Categories